The Civilizing Process

The Civilizing Process The Civilizing Process stands out as Norbert Elias greatest work tracing the civilizing of manners and personality in Western Europe since the late Middle Ages by demonstrating how the formation of s

  • Title: The Civilizing Process
  • Author: Norbert Elias Edmund F.N. Jephcott Eric Dunning Johan Goudsblom Stephen Mennell
  • ISBN: 9780631221616
  • Page: 186
  • Format: Paperback
  • The Civilizing Process stands out as Norbert Elias greatest work, tracing the civilizing of manners and personality in Western Europe since the late Middle Ages by demonstrating how the formation of states and the monopolization of power within them changed Western society forever.

    One thought on “The Civilizing Process”

    1. Norbert Elias,great sociolog, pure product of european culture in what it has of better. I have read one of his most famous book many years ago " La dynamique de l'Occident ". It highlighted the formation of Europe from the political organization of states. I discover this book which is a kind of mirror of it because it takes place at the domestic level. How gets organized the life at the concrete level of the individuals people : sexual behavior, way of knowing how to being at the table, things [...]

    2. This book was so cool. But that is just me. I think you would have to be a real history geek to enjoy it, but there is this whole section on medieval manner books that is hilarious. Norbert is trying to demonstrate the shift in consciousness that occurred as people lived in more complex societies, rather than on isolated feudal estates. His point is that behavior that we currently take for granted-- manners, civility--- had to be learned over time. The books he quotes were written for adults try [...]

    3. For Elias, people learn to obey a code of conduct, people are restrained and refined, and emotions are culturally constructed. He discusses sophistication of speech and our elaborate and refined use of language. He claims we have made it second nature to adopt a social milieu. Elias has a formula for the book - socio-genetic and psychogenetic (micro and macro) - consisting of three parts: 1. courtesy (middle ages, sixteenth century - time when Erasmus wrote his text) 2. civilitai (court society) [...]

    4. The methodology is extremely effective and well-outlined. Good for its subject matter and conclusions, but also its methods. This book was quite an experience to read and was very influential in my intellectual development.

    5. I read this book as filling in the gaps between Bourdieu and Gregory Clark. That is, fleshing out the connection between class-stratified aesthetics and macro-social secular shifts in behavior. Bourdieu seemed to think of aesthetics as ultimately arbitrary, serving only to signal and reinforce class distinctions, but I think if he were more rational, he could have seen how involved aesthetics (such as, for instance, the trend towards smaller knives at the dinner table) are with real social facto [...]

    6. Using etiquette books from the sixteenth through the nineteenth centuries, Elias fashioned a theory of the evolution of our emotional lives and our notions of our self that is provocative and profound. Since he tried to explain many of the things that interested Foucault, I was happy to learn that the journal Foucault Studies had a special issue earlier this year comparing Elias' ideas with those of Foucault. It might have changed my life if I had read this book thirty years ago when I first not [...]

    7. Dense, academic, and sprawling in its scope, this book gets at the root impulses that people use to separate themselves from each other: manners, class, money. The time period is the Middle Ages, the basement from which we have constructed our sense of modernity. Affective restraint figures prominently in the brinkmanship of class, consciously and unconsciously. Elias's argument has altered how I see the world.

    8. It's actually quite mind-opening. The stunning grand perspective of Elias on combining the psychological study and culture study to explain how the civilization evolve turned out not to be empty and weak which possibly common problem of "thinking big", but rather rich and sharp.I really like how he expands the topic on the conflict of civilization and culture under different culture discourse, and how such differences distinguish the core and appearance of social struggles in different countries [...]

    9. *The Civilizing Process* is dense, discursive, Germanic, and in some ways pre-professional in its sociology (Elias has to argue at length, for example, for a discipline of historical psychology that is now well-established), but also fascinating and, in places, hilarious. The first third of the book details the historical development of manners in the West (primarily France, Germany and England) through a survey of etiquette instructions from the early middle ages to the nineteenth century. This [...]

    10. The Civilizing Process (Hardcover) by Norbert Elias ILL This book is recommended by "Do Muslim Women Need Saving?"|17574515

    11. Very much a product of its time, this work argues for a correlation and indeed even causation between increasingly affected manners and the formation of centralized states. Part one is perfectly unreadable; part two is perfectly hilarious (if only because it borrows liberally from such masters of civil manners as Erasmus and Giovanni della Casa); part three is completely intolerable if you have an intellectual aversion to the word "feudalism" and get hives just from thinking about it; and part f [...]

    12. It is hard to explain this amazing book. Elias begins by explaining the difference between French and German cultures, tracing centuries of social/political/economic changes to come to some wild (in a good way) conclusions about "how come the French ended up like this and the Germans ended up like this?" Even though his parents died in the Holocaust, he's not German-bashing. His conclusions are so interesting and well-researched, tracing the rise of continental philosophy, the fall of aristocrac [...]

    13. Märchenbuch. Wenn euch die Geschichte gefällt, könnt ihr's glauben. Die Wirklichkeit ist reicher als die Erzählung und der Autor hat erwiesenermaßen in zumindest einem Fall gegen sein eigenes besseres Wissen geschrieben. "Der Mythos vom Zivilisationsprozeß", geschrieben als Reaktion auf das Büchlein, von Dürr befasst sich ausführlich mit dieser Buntheit.

    14. Hervorragender soziologischer Klassiker aus den 30iger Jahren des 20. Jahrh in dem Elias wie aus dem Vogelblick die Muster der gesellschaftlichen Zivilisationsentwicklung aufdeckt. Teilw. monotone Wiederholungen, sprachlich ungewohnt, aber verständlich. Insgesamt: sehr erhellend.

    15. It definitely influenced me on how I think about cultures. It provides a useful way to approach and address problems withing a community/culture.

    Leave a Reply

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *